Watch Grading System

Watch Condition Grading Guide

Every watch we sell is carefully inspected and graded using the following system to give you a clear, honest sense of condition beyond what you see in the photos.

1. Excellent (Collector-Grade)

  • Case & Dial: No visible marks, dents, or scratches. Sharp lines, untouched polishing.
  • Crystal: Flawless – no scratches, chips, or signs of wear.
  • Bracelet/Strap: Unworn or like new. No stretch or fading.
  • Movement: Fully functional, recently serviced or running within factory spec.
  • Overall: As close to new as possible for a vintage or pre-owned piece.

Perfect for collectors seeking showroom-level condition with full originality.

2. Very Good

  • Case & Dial: Light hairline scratches or tiny marks under close inspection. No major wear or damage.
  • Crystal: May show micro-scratches, but no chips or cracks.
  • Bracelet/Strap: Minimal signs of use; no major creasing or stretching.
  • Movement: Working well, may not be recently serviced but runs reliably.
  • Overall: A well-preserved piece that’s clearly been cared for.

Ideal for daily wearers who want a sharp vintage look without worrying about babying it.

3. Good

  • Case & Dial: Noticeable wear from age or use – small dings, surface scratches, or light fading.
  • Crystal: May show noticeable scratches, but still functional and legible.
  • Bracelet/Strap: Used but functional. May show stretch or visible signs of age.
  • Movement: Running but may benefit from future servicing.
  • Overall: Honest, original condition with character. No major flaws.

Perfect for those who value originality and patina over perfection.

4. Fair

  • Case & Dial: Heavier wear – dings, nicks, or noticeable polishing. Dial may have spotting or patina.
  • Crystal: Scratches or minor chips possible, still wearable.
  • Bracelet/Strap: Well-worn or replacement strap. Visible stretch or cracking.
  • Movement: Ticking but likely due for service or adjustment.
  • Overall: A watch with history and visible signs of it.

Best for restorers, project pieces, or someone seeking a daily with no stress.

5. Poor

  • Case & Dial: Major damage like dents, corrosion, deep scratches, or missing parts.
  • Crystal: Cracked or heavily scratched, may need replacement.
  • Bracelet/Strap: Damaged, broken, or missing.
  • Movement: Not running or in unknown condition.
  • Overall: Worn, non-original, or in need of repair.

Sold as-is. Read descriptions carefully – ideal for parts, projects, or restoration.

Additional Notes

  • We highlight any standout details (e.g. “dial is flawless” or “case shows signs of prior polishing”) in each listing.
  • All photos are unedited to accurately reflect current condition.
  • If you're unsure about a specific grade, feel free to reach out — we’re happy to provide more info or photos.